Written by Dr. Mohamed Elsayad
International doctors have always upheld the NHS. Overseas recruitment from the British Commonwealth proved critical to the service’s post-war survival. And in 1961, Lord Cohen famously confessed, “The whole of our hospital service would have collapsed if it had not been for the enormous influx of junior doctors from overseas”. By the 1970s, one third of NHS doctors were born and qualified abroad – and we couldn’t have managed without them. We still can’t.
Without the 38.3% of internationally trained talent the OECD documented in 2023, the NHS would grind to a chilling halt. So, why is it that latent systemic inequities remain so stubbornly unaddressed? And at what cost?
Lifting, not leading
According to the General Medical Council (GMC), licensed international medical graduates (IMGs) now make up 42% of the UK’s total medical workforce. Yet, research from the University of Plymouth shows that just 11.6% of IMGs progress to consultant or GP roles within five years of service – compared to 75% of UK-trained graduates.
Similarly, international doctors account for a large proportion of those delivering essential, day-to-day care in locally employed (LE) and speciality and associate specialist (SAS) roles. These positions are vital to keeping services running, but are far less likely to lead to senior clinic leadership, consultantships, or GP partnerships. Overseas doctors are, in effect, holding up a system that consistently fails to support them.
Systemic cracks
The issue is not competence. It’s systemic. The NHS openly acknowledges its reliance on overseas recruitment across documentation such as the 2020/21 People Plan, which set out to strengthen international partnerships to support workforce demand. Yet, the same system continues to offer overseas doctors fewer structured routes to long-term influence, autonomy, and advancement.
Designed to address this problem by allowing those with ‘equivalent knowledge’ to get onto the UK Specialist Register, the Certificate of Eligibility for Specialist Registration (CESR) is a positive step towards a solution on paper. However, inequities are still inherent in practice.
The CESR and similar process are documentation heavy and inconsistently supported across trusts and specialties, with doctors often encouraged to apply without being given protected time, access to required assessments, or guidance on evidencing competencies in ways that align with unspoken cultural expectations. This means struggling with a system that assumes prior familiarity, not just with UK norms, but with unwritten systemic preferences. Unlike their home-trained peers, overseas graduates have little prior knowledge of the idioms, behaviours, phrasing, and approaches preferred when framing their experience for consideration, for instance. Yet, the system remains blind to disadvantage, continuing to assume they’re on equal footing.
Damage in assumption
There’s real damage in such assumptions, even when there’s no ill intent. The NHS isn’t purposely designed to see international applicants fail. Yet, the GMC consistently finds that UK-trained graduates outperform them when it comes to specialty training recruitment. The respective 60% vs 23% success disparity is particularly striking given that IMGs are far more likely to rely on such routes for progression.
It all boils down to the fact that, while they may speak the language and have all the technical know, IMGs lack the cultural and systemic familiarity that domestically taught graduates automatically inherit via first-hand experience of and training within the NHS. This puts them at a significant, albeit unintentional, disadvantage.
Equality, not equity
NHS policy rightly emphasises fairness and equal standards, with formal processes applicable to all doctors regardless of background. Yet, equal treatment often fails to translate into equal opportunity.
Overseas doctors are expected to decipher unwritten rules and silent expectations that have shaped NHS culture for decades. They’re not only adapting to a new language, health system, and regulatory environment, but to unspoken unspoken cues, opaque practices, and culturally specific ideas about growth and assertiveness within an unfamiliar system, as well. Those trained in the UK do not have to make such a leap. Yet, international colleagues are rarely offered additional support to bridge this gap.
It’s no surprise, then, that the Medical Protection Society found that 58% of overseas doctors felt their induction was inadequate, with 48% experiencing significant anxiety about their clinical duties and 41% reporting feelings of isolation. These figures are markedly higher than among UK-trained doctors, reinforcing the reality that whilst experience may be equitable on paper, outcomes are not.
Consumed by anxiety
Of course, when inequities persist, the consequences extend beyond individual careers. Stalled progression and chronic uncertainty affect the entire NHS, eating into its very survival and progress.
In 2024, 4,880 overseas doctors relinquished their UK licences to practice, according to the GMC: a 26% increase on the previous year. The NHS cannot afford for dissatisfaction and systemic exclusion to continue driving attrition, particularly given its continued reliance on overseas recruitment. It must protect international doctors as a matter of priority – commitment that will also uphold its international reputation. This is vital if it is to keep key roles filled for long enough to ensure that the services gained outweigh the cost of visa sponsorship, relocation, induction, and eventually, rehiring following months of supervised practice. This means ensuring talent trained abroad gains fairer and more equitable access to promising career paths.
Two-way street – or a world of alternatives?
The opportunity to work in the UK may have been enough in the past. But nowadays, opportunities for progress matter. International doctors now have a plethora of competing opportunities at their feet, with the BMJ reporting that 49% of internationally qualified doctors surveyed by the GMC were considering at least one other country instead of the UK when weighing where to practice in 2024. Competitors included Australia, New Zealand, and Canada – all appealing destinations capable of offering progression. Moreover, approximately 13% of those already practicing here confessed they were ‘very likely’ to move abroad within the next 12 months according to the same source. Even when the UK is a given, there’s always the possibility of losing foreign talent to private practice.
External support from those with lived experience of national systems can help to address some of the system’s current challenges, but it shouldn’t fall on international colleagues to plug holes in a sinking ship that needs them more than they need it. It’s time we recognised programmes like the CESR for what they truly are: sticking plasters for a gaping wound that must be sutured if we are to revive the NHS.
About the author
Dr. Mohamed Elsayad is an experienced NHS Consultant Radiologist and a dedicated mentor for international medical graduates (IMGs) aiming to build successful careers in the UK healthcare system. Mentoring is improving communication skills is a necessity not luxury anymore, as such he has mentored and coached over 500 international doctors.