Could misinformation be fuelling the resurgence of smoking amongst Gen Z?

Here, Markus Lindblad, Head of External Affairs at Haypp, discusses the impact of misinformation, particularly among the younger generations.

The UK has seen a significant decline in daily smoking rates over the past decade. In 2011, the daily smoking rate was 20.2%. By 2024, this had more than halved, reducing to 9.1%. On the international stage, the UK is considered a success story.

An important driver of this success has been the transition of UK smokers to vapes. In 2024, for the first time, there were more vapers than smokers in the UK, with about 10% of adults using vapes. NHS guidance states that vaping is less harmful than smoking and that vaping is one of the most effective tools for quitting smoking.

Despite this, widespread misperceptions about vaping persist among the UK population. A major study by University College London looked at survey responses from 28,393 smokers in England between 2014 and 2023. In 2014, 44% of smokers regarded vapes as less harmful than cigarettes, and only 11% saying e-cigarettes were more harmful. By 2023, only 27% thought that vapes were less harmful, and 57% thought vapes were as harmful or more harmful than smoking.

Despite clear public health information that vaping is a better option than smoking, public perceptions about vapes have deteriorated to the point where more than half of smokers incorrectly believe that vaping is more harmful or as harmful as smoking.

This has dangerous implications for public health. For a smoker to decide to switch to a vape, a nicotine pouch or other alternative nicotine product, they must consider it a less harmful option. Research from ASH found that 56% of adults and 63% of young people now wrongly believe vaping is as harmful or more harmful than smoking. They point out that risk misperceptions are soaring and that there is now potential underuse of vapes for smoking cessation.

One of the drivers of this misunderstanding of risk is the steady stream of negative stories and misinformation about vaping in the media. While the media rarely reports on the terrible impact of smoking on UK families, presumably on the assumption that we are all well aware of the damage smoking does, we regularly see sensationalist and unfounded negative coverage of vapes.

For Gen Z, who may not have had the same exposure to anti-smoking information as previous generations, they are encountering negative information about vapes far more frequently than negative information about cigarettes. It is unsurprising, then, that their understanding of the relative risk between vapes and cigarettes is inaccurate.

A 2024 Haypp survey of 500 vape users found that just 27% said that they were aware of misinformation about vapes. In a 2021 report, the Royal College of Physicians recommended that mass media campaigns be used to redress false perceptions about the safety of vapes compared with cigarettes.

It’s time to bring some balance to the conversation about vaping in the UK. Yes, there are issues around underage access that need to be discussed and addressed through robust age-gating requirements and enforcement. However, the relentless misinformation about vapes now risks jeopardising the positive public health impact they can have as an alternative option for smokers who are trying to quit.