New international research has raised fresh questions about the effectiveness of “opt-out” organ donation laws, suggesting that presumed-consent systems may unintentionally reduce the number of living organ donors — potentially cancelling out small gains in deceased donation.
The study, led by researchers at the Vienna University of Economics and Business (WU), analysed data from 2000 to 2023 and found that countries switching to opt-out systems saw living donor numbers fall by nearly 30%. According to the authors, the psychological impact of presumed consent may lead many people to assume organ shortages are being addressed automatically, reducing their motivation to volunteer as living donors.
Lead researcher Pascal Güntürkün said the findings indicate that the widely held belief that opt-out laws provide a simple solution to donor shortages “needs re-examining.” He said:
“Opt-out defaults have long been viewed as a behavioural policy triumph. But our data show that their psychological spillover effects can blunt overall social impact.”
While deceased donor numbers rose slightly after the introduction of opt-out laws, the increase was small and statistically insignificant. When assessed alongside the sharp decline in living donors, overall organ supply may have remained unchanged or even worsened.
Impact on the UK
The UK adopted a soft opt-out system in stages between 2015 (Wales) and 2021 (Scotland), with England’s change taking effect in 2020. Despite hopes that the new laws would boost donation, NHS data shows only modest increases in deceased donation — and living donor numbers have fallen in recent years.
Living donors are especially important for kidney transplants, which make up the majority of UK transplant demand.
Current UK Organ Donation Landscape
| Category (UK) | Most Recent Figures | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| People on the transplant waiting list | ~7,300 | Demand has risen post-pandemic |
| Deceased donors in the last 12 months | 1,695 | Slight annual increase |
| Living donors in the last 12 months | 841 | Down from pre-pandemic levels (~1,000+) |
| Kidney transplants relying on living donors | ~30% | Living donors provide better long-term outcomes |
| Average waiting time for a kidney | 2.5–3 years | Longer for some blood and tissue groups |
(All data compiled from NHS Blood and Transplant)
Researchers Call for Renewed Focus on Living Donation
Given the central role of living donors for kidney transplantation, the authors argue that policymakers should avoid over-relying on opt-out legislation and instead:
- improve public awareness of ongoing donation needs
- highlight the unique importance of living donation
- support altruistic donor programmes
- provide stronger protections and follow-up care for living donors
The report concludes that presumed consent should be viewed as “only one part of a much wider donor-engagement strategy.”
As waiting lists continue to rise across Europe and the UK, the study suggests that encouraging living donation — rather than assuming opt-out systems alone will close the gap — will play a critical role in meeting future transplant needs.
Sources & References
-
Press release: Organ donation policies are reducing organ donors — ResponseSource
-
Vienna University of Economics and Business (WU) research summary
-
NHS Blood and Transplant: Annual Activity Reports & Organ Donation Statistics (2023–24)
Image: stock image